ADE at HOME Conference Tickets go on sale November 27! Get them 20% off Black Friday through Cyber Monday! Browse Products

ADE at HOME Conference Tickets go on sale November 27! Get them 20% off Black Friday through Cyber Monday! Browse Products

Episode 356: Voices from the Conference – A Joyful Looking Back by Susanne Norris

Today’s podcast episode is part of our occasional series, Voices from the Conference. We will be sharing with you Susanne Norris’ talk from this past year’s ADE @ Home Virtual Conference on conducting end of term exams. Enjoy!

Listen Now:

Charlotte Mason, Volume 6 (Amazon) (Living Book Press – use code DELECTABLE for 10% off!)

ADE Season 12 Reading Schedule

Susanne’s handout

ADE on YouTube

Emily
Welcome to A Delectable Education, the podcast that spreads the feast of the Charlotte Mason Method. I’m Emily Kiser and today’s episode is part of our occasional series, Voices from the Conference.  As you probably know by now, we at A Delectable Education host a virtual conference in February of each year, hopefully bringing some inspiration and encouragement to what is notoriously a dark stretch in the homeschooling year…at least for those of us in the northern hemisphere.

A few years ago, a worldwide pandemic forced us to move to the online format, and we discovered some benefits we wouldn’t have otherwise.  Not only are Charlotte Mason educators from all over the world able to join us due to the virtual platform, so many have personally written to share how they wouldn’t ever be able to get away for a conference or a retreat except online.  

We are so grateful to have the opportunity to pour into the broader Charlotte Mason community in this way. However, we know that many are still not able to participate, and even those that do often long for something more, and that brings us to the Voices of the Conference series. We use these episodes to highlight one of the speakers or ideas that came out of last year’s conference.  We hope you enjoy this little taste of conference and getting to know one of the speakers better.  We hope you join us at the next ADE conference in February.

Today we will be sharing Susanne Norris’ “A Joyful Looking Back,” where she discusses exams in the Charlotte Mason curriculum.  We hope you’ll understand why exams are a thing of delight rather than dread for our students and ourselves.

Susanne
Hi, I’m Suzanne Norris, and it’s good to be here with you all at the ADE conference this year.

Today, I’m going to be talking with you about examinations in a Charlotte Mason education. But first, let’s start with our conference prayer.

From Psalm 136:

“Give thanks to the Lord, for he is good, for his steadfast love endures forever. Give thanks to the God of Gods, for his steadfast love endures forever. Give thanks to the Lord of Lords, for his steadfast love endures forever.”

Amen. 

By way of a short introduction, I was born and raised in southern Oklahoma, went to university, and was discipled. I felt a deep call to mission work. I taught German and then English for about eight years at a few different universities, all while doing short-term mission trips to mostly German or Russian-speaking countries. 

I met my husband in Central Asia while doing a two-year term after graduate school. After getting married and spending a few years in Texas, we returned to Central Asia with our one-year-old son, and then we had three more children. We lived there, planting churches and being part of the work of evangelism and disciple-making for about eight more years. 

When my oldest was four, I began researching homeschooling options, as I knew our children would need to be at least partially homeschooled. Most of our teammates had their children in local schools but supplemented at home with English Language Arts, American History, Geography, et cetera. Learning about Charlotte Mason changed that for us, however. I had my first consult with Liz nine years ago when my oldest was five. 

We had to leave Central Asia a few years ago due to a medical situation with one of our dear children. We’re still amazed that the Lord led us north of the border to work among refugees and immigrants from Central Asia here in Western Canada, and the medical situation with our son has been resolved, praise God. Our kids are now 14, 13, 11, and 9. 

I’ve been homeschooling my children for the last eight years, learning about Charlotte Mason’s philosophy and methodology for a bit longer than that. It’s been a slow road for me as old habits, my own deficiencies, have been difficult barriers to overcome in seeing this vision realized for my own family. However, God is merciful. Children are both forgetful and forgiving, so there is hope for you if you are like me in this area. I urge you to keep learning, particularly in this area of examinations, because as you will hopefully see, the purpose and benefits of doing them the way our dear Charlotte describes are manifold, even if we don’t always execute them perfectly. 

While examinations and the idea of test-taking in general are not usually things to get excited about, even as a teacher in a traditional university setting, I did not enjoy giving or grading exams, but I hope you will see that there is another way.

As a student myself, I recall cramming for exams late into the night, using mnemonic devices that had nothing to do with the content in order to recall things, stressing over exams to the point of extreme anxiety. All of this only to forget everything I had memorized within days of taking the exam.

As Miss Mason said, and which I will reiterate later, 

“Self-education is the only possible education. The rest is mere veneer laid on the surface of a child’s nature.” (6.240) 

Our kids will have opportunities to learn test-taking skills later. They do not need to have their education catered to exams they will need to pass years down the road. Exams Charlotte Mason’s way turns all of this on its head and lets the child shine in their exams if only we follow the principles and practices she laid out. The closer we can get to her standard, the smoother and more delightful exams will be.

As an overview of this workshop, I’d like to first describe the purpose and benefits of exams in PNEU schools. Second, outline major differences between Charlotte Mason examinations and what we would think of as traditional school exams, which by the way, are things you might like to avoid if you’re attempting a Charlotte Mason education for your students.

Next, I’ll talk about the methods you can use for exams in Charlotte Mason schools, then share a bit with you about how exams have looked in our home over the years, and then lastly, give you a few final thoughts.

First, let’s consider the purpose and benefits according to Charlotte Mason and her schools. We will discuss two quotes, one from Charlotte Mason herself in volume six, and another from a Parents Review article. 

In volume six, she succinctly says, 

“The terminal examinations are of great importance. They are not merely and chiefly tests of knowledge, but records which are likely to be permanent.” (6.272)

They’re permanent in two senses that I can see. The mother has the literal permanent record, but furthermore, if exams are done in the way she laid out, the delectable knowledge itself is permanent. She also says here that they are not merely or chiefly to be tests of knowledge. So what were the chief purposes if not to test knowledge? 

That brings me to our second quote. In the article, “Conditions for Schools Using PUS Programs,” it says, 

“To focus a term’s work, to guide and encourage isolated teachers, as in fact most teachers are, even though enmeshed in the most rigorous examination nets that official co- control can devise…. to guide also those who plan the work.” (1932 PR article)

This is an excellent article. I’ve linked it in my handout.

So to set and focus a term’s work for the people. Students are able to look back at the term’s work and feel its fullness. They feel the reward of accomplishment when they see the scope of what they’ve done in the term. What a delight to pull back out the recitations, the poems, and books they’ve tackled this term. I believe this is the primary purpose of examinations. 

Next, to hold the teacher accountable and to be a guide. The teachers at PNEU schools were “enmeshed in rigorous nets” as they said, but were still isolated and could get off track, so to speak. There have been times I myself have come to exams and realized I have left out a major piece of a particular subject, or was missing the mark on what was really important in the lesson. The exams help set this standard. 

And then finally, to assess the quality of materials and books, and to make changes for the for the future if necessary. Charlotte Mason used exams to evaluate whether a book was up to par. If children consistently cannot narrate from a particular book, we may need to make a change. They in particular had a bird’s eye view on what materials were being narrated well. Over the years, I have looked to the ladies at ADE to be my guide in this way. Even though they are not receiving or reviewing my children’s examinations, their knowledge of living books, as well as the vast range of home educators they interact with each year give them a unique and particular wisdom in this area.

So, what are a few of the benefits of administering exams Mason’s way? Well, I’m absolutely certain there are more. Here are a few that I see. First, narrating for a second time after a considerable amount of time has lapsed ensures long-term memory is engaged. As students get older, these kinds of delayed narrations become more common, but our kids can get a taste of them and begin exercising that muscle during their examinations. 

Next, there is a record of the child’s work, which can be used to see their progress, but also when the time comes for transcript-making, you will have a clear paper trail. 

Then, it gives the child a landmark to end the term or school year. Homeschooled children in particular need this kind of marker so that one term or year does not simply flow into the next without any acknowledgement. This landmark can be a celebratory week of exams that looks a lot like a normal week, or you can get creative and change things up a bit.

Next, knowing there will be an exam question or two does something to our minds in helping us take things more seriously. We shouldn’t use this truth to weaponize exams, but students are more motivated in their lessons if they know the knowledge could reappear on an examination. There’s just no way around this. If you routinely skip exams in a particular subject, you are inadvertently telling your student that subject is not important. I’ll come back to this later, but it is better to shorten an exam question or perhaps let the exam replace the last lesson of the year, rather than cut it out entirely because of the messaging it sends to your student. There is grace for difficult seasons, of course.

Another benefit is that they are a delight. This should be a joyful looking back. That’s the standard Charlotte Mason schools set based on the quote above. If there are tears or I find myself discouraged, I know I am missing the mark. Our children’s education is much more than what they can produce on any given exam.

Let’s move on to talk about some major differences between traditional test-taking we more than likely experienced and what we are trying to accomplish. First, we are not trying to discover holes in their knowledge. They are not trying to prove to us that they learned everything they ought to have. If we can remain cheerful, particularly if there’s effort on their part, it will go a long way in helping them feel successful, which will help them actually be successful. 

In the article, “Examinations in the PNE School and School Affiliated”, Ms. G.H.A. Stephens writes, 

“They (the children) are encouraged to regard the examinations more as an exhibition of what they can do than as a test of their strength and weakness.” 

Most children love this.

In a similar vein, we are to accept what the students give us. This was one of the biggest hurdles for me personally. In general, we might need to lower our expectations, particularly for younger students and students new to this kind of testing. Try not to take it personally if they cannot tell you about the Luck of Troy or describe the boundaries of a field. Sometimes the phrasing can throw our kids off, and they will improve if you are consistent over time.

In volume six, Charlotte Mason says, 

“The children write with perfect understanding, as far as they go, and there is rarely a howler in hundreds of sets of papers. They have an enviable power of getting at the gist of a book or a subject. Sometimes they are asked to write verses about a personage or an event. The result is not remarkable by the way of poetry, but sums up a good deal of thoughtful reading in a delightful way.” (6.242)

Notice her words here. She says the result is not remarkable, and she was completely fine with that. She said it still summed up a good deal of thoughtful reading in a delightful way. What a wonderful spin on unremarkable poetry. 

If you have a student who is not giving their best effort, some time spent rooting out the reason would probably be my best advice. Are there other areas of life in which that student isn’t giving their best effort, or was this a one-off? If so, let it go. If this is becoming a pattern with your child, some habit training could be in order. Refer to Miss Mason’s extensive writings on habit training for help. 

As your students progress in this method, what they produce on their examinations will increase. I’ve been amazed at how much my children have to say and write about a particular topic. In fact, if they don’t have much to say or write, as they get older, not necessarily in Form 1, it helps me know something might need to change in how we are executing that lesson.

In Volume 6, Charlotte Mason says, 

“During the examinations, which last a week, the children cover, say, from 20 to 60 sheets of Cambridge paper according to age and class. But if 10 times as many questions were set on the work studied, most likely they would cover 10 times as much paper.” (6.241)

This has been true to my experience as well. As their science of relations and their ability to write grows, they’re steadily producing better work.

Another difference is that there’s no studying or teaching to the test. As the earlier quote stated, exams were not chiefly about what the child knew. Refer back to the benefits I listed on this one. It goes against the way most of us were educated, but we know that most revising and reviewing only works for short-term memorization, but narrating is what makes learning stick.

Next, there are no grades, at least in the early years. This will need to be researched on a state, country, provincial basis as your students reach high school. However, in general, students do not need to be shown or even given grades. These can be deterrents in many ways, and while there are some benefits, the negatives often outweigh those. This is something we just need to trust Charlotte Mason and countless home educators on.

“Self-education is the only possible education. The rest is mere veneer laid on the surface of a child’s nature.” (6.240)

This is from Volume 6, page 240. I love this quote, and often use it as a measuring stick when thinking about lessons and exams.

Let’s discuss what Charlotte Mason says about grades and the danger that lies in using them. In chapter eight of part two in the book Ourselves, Miss Mason warns the students against the allure of grades in the school room. She says, 

“Many boys and girls take pleasure in going to school not for the sake of what they learn there, but for the sake of the marks which give them places above certain of their classmates. They should understand that marks and places and the power to pass examinations is all they get. As Mr. Ruskin has said, ‘They cram to pass and not to know.’ They do pass, and they don’t know. Knowledge as an abiding joy comes only to those who love her for her own sake and not to those who use her to get on in school or in life.” (5.79)

In chapter 20 of Volume 2, which is Parents and Children, as well as part 2, chapter 8 of Ourselves, Miss Mason lays out a compelling argument against competitive examinations. I encourage you to read it in full if this topic be of interest to you. To sum up the chapter here, she says, 

“Observe the evil lies in the competition, not in the examination. If the old axiom be true that the mind can know nothing but what it can produce in the form of an answer to a question put by the mind to itself, it is relatively true that knowledge conveyed from without must needs be tested from without. Probable work on a given syllabus tested by a final examination is the condition of definite knowledge and steady progress. All we contend for is that the examination shall not be competitive.” (2.218)

“Emulation is an easier spring to work than curiosity,” she says. Emulation in this context means an effort to match or surpass a person or achievement. Competitive examinations, they are just too alluring for the child. Their strong and natural curiosity for knowledge is curtailed by their desire to be at the top of the class. She does not vilify effort and a desire to succeed. She writes that they’re natural and necessary. However, in the school room, she says of emulation that 

“the balance of character is destroyed by the constant stimulation of this one desire at the expense of the rest.” (2.220)

As most of us probably do not hang lists of our children’s rankings on the kitchen wall, what does this have to do with us? In my case, my children were born very close in age, and they often want to know who the best in algebra is or who gave the better recitation, et cetera. This can even happen between my students who are five years apart. They are very susceptible to this. I shut it down quickly, because I know they are in danger of what Miss Mason describes above, that their desire for emulation will overpower their desire for knowledge, which we know is delectable. However, this desire can be stamped out in the student, which isn’t insurmountable, but we would be wise to avoid getting into the situation to begin with.

So, what are some methods Charlotte Mason laid out for exams? How did she propose we carry out examinations in our homes? General principles would include these tests would take place week 12 of each term, but often begin in week 11 for us. I plan for 10 weeks of lessons, which I learned from Emily Kiser, which allows week 11 for anything that doesn’t get done in the 10 weeks, or for subjects that have more lessons that can be done in 10 weeks. For us, that’s often Bible, Plutarch, Science, Math. However, many lessons have concluded by week 11, therefore I can slip in the exam to the normal lesson time on that day. This is dependent on the number of students you have and their ages, but as my students have grown, they do increasingly independent exams. 

Next, follow a schedule like your weekly schedule. It’s wise to not change up the schedule too much, particularly as regards the parts of the brain being used in the lesson. You’ll want to alternate an exam that requires a lot of writing, for example, with one that is more oral, like for Foreign Language or Math. You’ll also want to keep the exams to the time amounts of your day, so not going over two and a half hours for your youngest and not over four for your oldest.

Next, make every effort to require an exam for every school lesson. This is daunting, I know. I counted 28 exams for my Form 3 student last spring. The sum of those included his final recitation pieces, showing his father a term handicraft, a brush drawing, or a nature journal entry, recording himself reciting a Russian or German song, poem, et cetera. They’re not all written exams for which you need to be present, but if we’re consistently skipping, say, the examination for grammar, we are inadvertently sending the message that this lesson isn’t important, and they will feel less motivation to pay careful attention if they know they will not be tested on a particular subject. Life happens, and some seasons are wilder than others, but make an attempt to not miss the same exams term by term by term. 

Next, keep a record of your students’ answers, be they recorded or written. When my children were young, recorded… I recorded many of their narrations, and words cannot express to you how precious those files are to me now. Hearing their little voices talk about Phillis Wheatley or a butterfly they observed in the backyard gives me a deep sense of gratefulness. It’s akin to reading back through their earliest written narrations, in that we can see a bigger jump in progress. Some of this is like watching hair grow day by day. However, comparing oral and written narrations year by year can be a helpful and encouraging habit, rather than looking for that day-to-day growth.

Next, there was a note on some programs that no work needed to be sent up by the PNEU members and schools for the summer examinations. That would be after term three. This was noted in Program 96 as well as others. What this shows us is that things were not nearly as strict as we may assume. If Easter fell late in a year, exams were skipped. Do with that information what you will.

Next, examinations should be more open-ended in nature in the early years, and when possible, provide the student with options to choose from. In subjects such as Math and Grammar, where the questions cannot be open-ended, choose problems that you know your student will be able to answer. We are not trying to trip them up or catch them in something they don’t know. 

These are our children. They are some of our nearest neighbors, deserving of our respect and love. We, more than anyone else, know where they are, where their strengths and weaknesses are. The time to work on their weak spots is during daily lessons and during habit training, not exam week. This should be a merry ending of a term or school year, not a reason to fret or feel guilty. 

I am preaching to myself here as well, since this is still a struggle for me. My younger children are certainly benefiting from how much I have grown over these eight years, and God has been gracious to my older children, where I failed the methods.

In the article “Conditions for Schools Using PUS Programs” it is written, 

“The work which shows best in examination is unquestionably that which at the time when the lesson was taken was most marked by the interest of assimilation. An account of an event or person or scientific phenomenon understood and told back or narrated intelligently does remain permanent without any of the traditional revision for the examinations found necessary in nearly all the schoolwork.” 

This quote tells us a lot. Teachers were encouraged to choose exam questions based on lessons in which their students showed the most interest. What a paradigm shift for us. They’ll remember that.

 I’d like to show you a few example exam questions. Some of these I made up, and some came from programs. 

Bible, Form 1: “Tell about Jesus being tempted in the wilderness. What do you know about God calling the Israelites out of Egypt?” 

Reading, Form 1: “Father to choose unseen passage.” 

US History, Form 2: “What do you know about Franklin D. Roosevelt, Winston Churchill, and World War II?” 

French, Form 2: “Make up a short French conversation about the weather, food, et cetera.” 

Literature, Form 3: “Write a short account of the character of (A) Julius Caesar, (B) Marc Antony, as they appear in Shakespeare’s Julius Caesar.” 

Dictation, Form 3: “Choose a paragraph from one of the student’s lesson books (novel, Geography, Shakespeare).”

Next, I’d like to give you some insight into how our exam weeks have gone over the years. Here are the examination books I give my students who are writing their narrations. Previously, I had them using their normal narration books, but I prefer this method as everything is now kept together over the years. I have them write the date and subject before beginning the written narration. 

I also have a teacher binder where I store ADE’s examination helps as well as examinations from particular curriculum I’m using. I’ve printed and laminated ADE’s list of subjects by form for each form I have. It’s a nice concise list of every subject a student has per term. I use that to tick off examinations as we accomplish them. If a subject has multiple examinations because there are multiple books that were read, I do a simple numbering system and check those off within the subject as we complete them. You may have a much better way of keeping track of what’s been completed, but I was getting lost in all the exams a few days in and needed an easier way to track what we had left to do. 

Your exam week won’t necessarily follow the same exact schedule you normally use, but it’s a good jumping off point. I usually begin our examination week with Old Testament. I send my oldest three off with their questions and exam booklets, then sit with my youngest as she dictates her narration to me. But if you have more Form 1 or earlier students, it might behoove you to have one do their handwriting exam or simply take a break while you work with the other independent student. 

When I had multiple children who were not yet writing narrations, I often used the voice memo app on my phone. Now that three of my students are writing most of their examinations, I am able to write or simply listen to my younger student. She does a few lessons with voice memo, mostly because I love to have her little voice saved that way. 

Next, I take my children out for a few examinations if time allows. We go out for hot chocolate in the winter or ice cream at the end of term three. Even a picnic if the budget doesn’t currently allow for splurges. I cannot get through as many exams in one day using this method, but it’s still worth it occasionally. I involve my husband and other family members if possible. I know of moms who put on a sort of exam fair where the students display work and perform recitations, and foreign language songs or poems, et cetera, but I have not personally done this. Mostly because I’m tired by the end of the term.

Finally, I’d like to share a few final thoughts and preemptively answer a few questions. 

What if my student can tell me nothing? I’ve had this happen. This can take troubleshooting on our part, but generally from term to term and year to year, you will be seeing improvements. Use your best poker face in the moment. I don’t think it’s necessarily wrong to express to your student that you expected more or rather something, but now’s probably not the time for a lecture at least. We can take these kinds of situations personally. 

After all, we have worked very hard to implement their education, but we need daily reminders that we are the seed sowers, not the growth giver, and growth happens at different rates, and mostly is not determined by us. The Holy Spirit is indeed their indefatigable teacher, and as Ms. Mason says in volume two, 

“We do not sufficiently rejoice in the wealth that the infinite nature of our God brings to each of us.” (2.273)

She also says that God does indeed instruct and teach the people. We have much work to do, don’t misunderstand me. But our work is more in laying the feast, providing resources, organizing the time, not ensuring they learn what we want them to learn and when they learn it.

Big surprise, but I highly recommend ADE’s exam planner under teacher helps. You can absolutely peruse the Charlotte Mason digital collection and look at individual exams, but there are a lot of them, and ADE has organized and synthesized the information there so well, it really is worth it. I don’t even necessarily use the exam questions they recommend, as it’s often from a different book entirely. Seeing the kind of questions asked set for a specific form and subject allows me to easily interject our own material. 

I don’t recommend coming up with exam questions completely on your own, as PNEU schools level exams up from form to form. The kind of questions asked of Form 2 students are quite different from Form 5, even if they’re studying the same topic.

Many of the curriculum helps I use include exam questions that are specific to the work set, like Geography, and Science, Math, even Literature. I can just slip those into the normal lesson time, particularly for my strong readers.

Lastly, will this prepare your students for standard tests they may someday be forced to take? No. My children take required standardized tests every two years, and it’s always a struggle. I’m actually quite happy that they’re not used to sitting for hours taking multiple choice tests, as their time has been much better employed. All of my children respond differently to this situation. Some of them like the challenge and do okay, despite the fact that they’re not used to them. Others give up halfway through and score terribly. All of them were nervous for weeks before and exhausted afterward. 

These are test-taking skills. They have nothing to do with real knowledge, so we must see them for what they are. Sometimes necessary, but not worth working ourselves up over. Before your student’s required to take college entrance exams or something similar, they more than likely will need to do some reading about those exams and take a few prep tests. But in case you didn’t know, many students do this, regardless of how many or few standardized tests they have taken over the years, and Charlotte Mason made allowances for this. 

On a side note, Charlotte Mason’s style of examinations are much more in line with the kind of comprehensive examinations I took when finishing up my master’s degree in German Literature. There were open-ended questions that required me to write what I knew and connect dots across a range of fields.

To conclude, this won’t be easy, and it will require you to sit down the weekend or so before to make a plan. Pray. Ask the Holy Spirit to give you perspective and grace concerning each of your students. He has given both you and them everything you need for life and godliness, as 2 Peter 1:3 tells us. Making an effort to reach the standard Ms. Mason set won’t ensure that your homeschool’s perfect. She herself said, 

“Let me repeat that I venture to suggest not what is practicable in any household, but what seems to me absolutely best for the children, and that in the faith that mothers work wonders when they are convinced that wonders are demanded of them.” (1.44)

What I understand this to mean is that while we may not always be able to achieve the very high standards she set forth, it is worth the effort to strive and make improvements year by year, both in the lesson weeks of our term, as well as in exam week. If we can keep the primary goal before us, that exams are to be a joyful looking back at the term’s work, we will go far in reaching that high standard she set for the children’s sake. 

May exams in your homeschool be Spirit-led and a delight to your children.

Leave a reply